The American Dilemma and How We Can Fix It


This being February 21st I realize that many of you will feel this post is ill-timed.  After all, President’s Day is supposed to be celebrated on the third Monday of February.  In actuality the day is a commemoration of the birthday of the first President of the United States, George Washington.  The official name for the day is still Washington’s Birthday.  President’s Day is a gratuitous addition.

Until 1971 we used to commemorate the day by observing it on our first President’s actual birthday – which is February 22nd.  Falling between the cusp of the official observation and the actual date of the event may make me politically incorrect.  I hope so.  In fact, that is my essential reason for offering this post on this particular day.

I was thinking about how George Washington led us to victory to become an independent nation.  But that led me to think on other matters – prompted by the fact that I was following the important debate on “illegal aliens” and the effect they were having on our less than robust economy.  I couldn’t help but bring my historical training into this matter as I considered this very divisive issue.

Every so often I like to put myself in another person’s shoes.  That’s what I’m going to attempt in this post.  After all, the problem of “illegal aliens” isn’t a new one.  It is something that the indigenous American populations must have worried about as well.

Picture this – the year is 1626.  The Lenape Indians decide to accept an offer of twenty-four dollars’ worth of trinkets  and sell Manhattan Island to the Dutch.  Bad deal you may say.  Well it set off a chain of events whose consequences would be compounded over the next four hundred years.

You see, the fact is that the native Americans weren’t all that bright.  They signed treaty after treaty with the Palefaces – expecting us to honor our word.  We ignored most of the agreements we made in these treaties and did what we found more expedient for us.  (Did you know that we are still officially at war with the Seminoles in Florida).

Whether our ancestors were Irish or English or Dutch or Italian or whatever, we are all intruders in the land that belonged to those who were here before us.   We are usurpers who have legitimized our dominance through the promulgation of “The Monroe Doctrine” which granted us the right to expand as fast and as far as we could as the masters of the continent.

The fact that there were indigenous people in our way proved to be only a minor inconvenience.  We were successful in eradicating this stumbling block which barred our expansionary lust by killing a large percentage of them and confining most of the rest to reservations where they could live in sub-standard conditions. 

Of course, we were not alone in our treatment of native populations.  The Spanish did an even more effective job in dealing with the Incas in South America.  I guess that no matter where you are or who your are if you stand in the way of “progress” you’re going to get steam-rolled.

But isn’t it ironic?  The descendants of those Spanish conquistadors represent a large percentage of the “illegal aliens” about whom we are concerned today.  Some call this issue a “problem.”  Or is it perhaps just  karma.

Happy Birthday, President Washington.

Comments on: "ON PRESIDENT’S DAY" (8)

  1. Couldn’t agree more.

  2. Yes it is a complicated issue indeed. The facts are those we often think of as originals have in many cases displaced people who went before them and waves of immigration are now displacing those who displaced. I’m afraid that situation is not going to change as the reason for the displacement is survival. People who are unable to feed themselves or their families will go where they can better their situation. While the western nations are now accused of colanialism, which is a part of bettering their situation, those colonized are now economically colonizing the colonizers. Case in point is China the lender to the world now, and India which now takes the jobs of the colonizers. In 100 years from now the world will have a different set of haves and have nots and reverse migrations will occur.

    • You are ever so right. I remember as a child learning the map of Africa. There were the Belgian and French Congos just to cite a few of the names that have disappeared and been replaced. You have your aborigines, the Kiwis have the Maori – and, of course, who was there first, the Palestinians or the Jews. The list is endless – but the solution quite simple – that is there are simply too many of us roaming the earth. (It’s a horrific thought but not an original one). I would refer you back several centuries to Jonathan Swift’s satire, ” A Modest Proposal.” Also, if you’re not already familiar with them you might want to check out what has been described as the American Stonehenge. They’re called the Georgia Guidestones. In the end the underlying basis of war is overpopulation – now that we have greatly erradicated much disease which played its part in maintaining a natural balance. (I think I need an adult drink now).

  3. If utopia is war and starvation – we have it in abundance. I doubt that’s what Thomas More had in mind when he penned the book of that title.

  4. This is a great post about an area of our history that many (most?) sweep beneath a carpet of denial. Illegal alien, indeed. Karma. You said it!

  5. That’s how I view it as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: